Democracy and Documentary: A Conversation with Astra Taylor


March 30, 2016

By Shannon Foskett

When activist-writer-director Astra Taylor pitched Lea Marin at the NFB on the idea for her next documentary, the year was 2013 – a “somewhat complacent political moment,” as Taylor puts it. Obama had won re-election, the frenzied heights of the Occupy movement had faded, and it seemed important to begin a new process of questioning the economic and political order.


But if 2008 is seared into the historical record as the year that threw the globe into a financial crisis so exceptional in scope and structure that it rendered existing introductory economics textbooks useless (as one econ professor told me), ten years later global democracy itself seems to have fallen into a critical state of exception. Since January 2017, social comment in the U.S. has expressed endless variations on the theme of “just when I thought things couldn’t get worse…” – through to mid-terms, when nothing less than the idea of constitutional crisis was on the table.


The same ten years also marks the period between Taylor’s second and third films. But she didn’t have any of these resonances in mind as she began planning and shooting the bulk of what became What Is Democracy? (Canada, 2018, 107 min), a nominee for the Grand Jury Award at Sheffield Doc Fest. Taylor had begun planning a film on standing up to neoliberalism. Like the majority of us, high-tech polling included, Taylor expected the film would be released into the version of reality in which Hillary Clinton became America’s first female president. Given the “black swan” type events which actually transpired, perhaps what isn’t at all surprising is how much of a chord she says her new film has been striking with audiences around the globe. “There’s a general feeling of despondency,” Taylor says. “it’s not just in the U.S.”


Given the pace of her current film promotion and book editing schedule (Democracy May Not Exist, but We’ll Miss It When It’s Gone arrives in early 2019), I felt immensely honoured to have the opportunity to speak with Astra by phone after her arrival in Dublin. While the better part of our call was spent talking about the film’s production and documentary methods, we also waded into issues at the intersection of democracy and technology: predatory advertising; “deep fakes;” the Signal app; automation (or “fauxtomation,” as Taylor has convincingly argued); A.I., and the need for placing outside constraints (such as state-level legislation) on technological development.


As she told me, though, while the documentary could have gone further into some of these topics – Wendy Brown does raise the problem of technocracy– she had just finished writing The People’s Platform: Taking Back Power and Culture in the Digital Age (2014), which already covers many of these issues, and it was time to take a step back and re-examine some of our most basic, widely-held assumptions such as that of democracy itself. So she went back to original texts (Plato, Rousseau) and delved into research on the origins of capitalism.


So it is that I learned that the Bank of Siena (Italy) is the oldest existing bank in continuous operation, dating back to 1472. It was important for Astra that the film emphasize continuities such as this. Because of capitalism’s tendency to place a premium on novelty and innovation in general, increased demands on production lead to the hyper-specialization and the division of collective temporality into ever-smaller units of exchange. In this way, contemporary structures are tightly bound up in mythologies that erase the fact that a longer history tends to sit behind most things. We might forget that even democracy has a complicated history, for example, and that it is still only a partially realized goal. As an idea it dates back to the 6thcentury BCE, but it hasn’t been until the last several decades that most Western nations have even begun to approach what we would want to call genuine social democracies, and even there it depends on how one understands the scope of the concept.


As it turns out, this line of questioning also leads back to Siena, which, I also learned, is the location of the first secular fresco on the topic of government. So it’s fitting that the film begins and ends with the scene in the Palazzo Pubblico, where the three panels of Ambrogio Lorenzetti’s Allegory of Good and Bad Government unfurl above on the walls. As Astra pointed out, its visual layout is itself quite cinematic – involving some degree of inherent montage, one might say, as the viewer’s eye is inducted into the labor of comparative reading through spatial juxtapositions. Taylor herself spent hours discussing this early Renaissance representation of government with Silvia Federici (who also owns a copy of it), each of them often circling back around to the same few depictions, and as we know from the film, finding unexpected new readings in light of contemporary perspectives.


What was intriguing for me to hear was that editing the film (footage for which had been gathered as far back as 2011) wasn’t the biggest challenge – Astra knew the parts she liked and wanted to keep – but she told me that she’d originally felt the least sure about how this interpretative dialogue – a feminist discussion of a 14thcentury painting – might translate for the film world, which is often committed to its own internal standards (be these formalist or market-related, both of which converge on a desire for innovation). To the NFB’s credit, Astra tells me, they encouraged her slower-paced, circumambulatory foray into extended lines of historical questioning and told her to take her time with it, to “make it even more philosophical.” No where else would she have been given that kind of support, she says.


From the start, however, it was important for Astra that the documentary avoid extremes of overbearing didacticism, on the one hand, and formal aestheticism, on the other. Taylor didn’t want to come down as “having a certain opinion” going in, but also wanted to steer away from the visual lull of beautiful images that don’t do any critical work. The result is a film whose methods embody its object and goals of inquiry: democracy can be found in the title (an open-ended question); in the deliberately intersectional range of participants and conversations; and in the locations: much of it is shot in the U.S. (some key scenes at a Trump rally) and Greece (Plato’s Academy, but also at the ports welcoming refugees from Syria, and in the rooms of a volunteer medical collective seeking to democratize access to health care in the wake of Greece’s economic crisis) – both of which have recently experienced dramatic failures in democratic process.


Most revelatory, however, is Taylor’s characteristic approach of simply filming conversation itself and giving a range of voices a chance to be heard (she told me that many she spoke to enthusiastically welcomed her, grateful for the opportunity to share their views). While the “talking head” has been a formal device long-maligned by film critics and scholars for its implicit imposition of authority and power relations, this is – quite fascinatingly – the exact opposite of what happens in What is Democracy?. Striking a balance between including herself (not always in the frame; but always a diegetic voice); following conversations outdoors as much as within institutional settings; and giving average people she runs into in the streets as much or more screen time as professional scholars themselves, Taylor’s collective portrait sits closer to the ideals implicit within ancient Athenian government, wherein selection of representatives by lottery – “anyone off the street” – both presumed and enabled an equality of investment in collective outcomes (notwithstanding the fact that their lottery excluded women, slaves and immigrants).


In other words, What Is Democracy? is more than just a question or the cinematic crowd-sourcing of a word’s meaning. The film interrogates democracy in practice as much as theory: the democratization of democracy, if you will – enacting an arrangement in which participation and access to the determination of its meaning is given equally to everyone. This is part of the reason why the film will show you none of the symbolic clichés often used to stand in for democracy: a long shot of the White House; people standing at voting booths; all those “I voted!” stickers on coats and faces. As recent history has shown, voting is necessary, but alone not sufficient, for creating a public sphere which embodies the ideals that many think are essential to democracy: freedom; equality; justice; genuinely distributed power.


One function of art (taken in its most inclusive scope) is its ability to retain and convey to future generations the lived experiences of those in the past: their hopes, their struggles, their knowledge and ignorance. With the rise of industrial and technological processes, our sense of the past, present and future has shortened considerably since the early modern era that followed soon after Lorenzetti’s painting. As so many critics and philosophers have pointed out (Walter Benjamin, Herbert Marcuse; Guy Debord; Bernard Stiegler, to name a few), these changes have had consequences on lived experience at the most intimate levels: everything from sleep to the loss of deep memory and a decline in the ability to imagine (which leads in part to the production and overdependence on the visual clichés mentioned above).


The strength of What Is Democracy? lies in its insistence on working against the conditioned tendencies of contemporary life: engaging in deliberate thinking; listening to all voices; digging up assumptions; working across institutional contexts and juxtaposing the contradictions in global structures that mainstream journalism often fails to capture. In this way, Taylor’s film fills an under-addressed niche for bringing criticism to a wider audience by making it visually accessible. More than this: in doing so, it suggests a rethinking of the historical forms and meaning of education along the same lines the film has done with democracy itself. It even points back to an early modernist moment for cinema, when its universalist faces (its ability to transcend language and geographical boundaries, for one) were seen through the promise of the young medium to humanity itself.


What Is Democracy? (2018)screens at 7pm, November 28, at the CIGI Campus Auditorium, 67 Erb St. W., in Waterloo.

Read article


CIGI Cinema Series: What Is Democracy? – Nov 28

HomePage, NewsletterMay2016, NewsletterSummer2016

March 30, 2016

Wed, 28 November 2018
7:00 PM – 9:00 PM EDT
Add to Calendar

CIGI Campus Auditorium
67 Erb St. W.
Waterloo, Ontario N2L 6C2
View Map

About What Is Democracy?

Coming at a moment of profound political and social crisis, What Is Democracy? reflects on a word we too often take for granted.

Director Astra Taylor’s idiosyncratic, philosophical journey spans millennia and continents: from ancient Athens’ groundbreaking experiment in self-government to capitalism’s roots in medieval Italy; from modern-day Greece grappling with financial collapse and a mounting refugee crisis to the United States reckoning with its racist past and the growing gap between rich and poor.

Featuring a diverse cast—including celebrated theorists, trauma surgeons, activists, factory workers, asylum seekers, and former prime ministers—this urgent film connects the past and the present, the emotional and the intellectual, the personal and the political, in order to provoke and inspire. If we want to live in democracy, we must first ask what the word even means.

Register Now


Film Partnership logos

The Centre for International Governance Innovation (CIGI), is pleased to announce a new partnership with the Grand River Film Festival, and THEMUSEUM to deliver public film screening events throughout the year.


Read article


Newsletter Signup

HomePage, NewsletterFall2016

March 30, 2016

Stay up to date with the latest local film industry happenings by signing up for our monthly e-newsletter!

We’ll keep you in the know on:

  • GRFF news
  • Film production in Waterloo Region
  • Local film premieres and events
  • Volunteer opportunities
  • Inspired film picks

Sign-up is free!  Just fill out the form below with your name and email address!

Join the mailing list

Your Name:*
Type the characters you see here:

Read article



HomePage, NewsletterFall2016

March 30, 2016

Application form

Each year, GRFF relies on volunteer film enthusiasts to present a festival of great film and programs. People are needed to assist in all areas of the festival – there is a role for everyone! As ambassadors for both the Festival and the Region of Waterloo, being pleasant, helpful and professional are key requirements for a GRFF volunteer.

Even though you are helping us out immensely, volunteering can also benefit you! These benefits can include real life skills for your resumé, tickets to GRFF screenings, the fabulous experience of taking part in a film festival, and high school community service hours.

If you are interested in lending your time and talents to GRFF, email for further information.

What type of volunteer position are you looking for?*
Tell us how you heard about GRFF and why you would like to volunteer:
Type the characters you see here:

* Indicates required fields

Opportunities for 2017 include:

Fundraising Committee Members 
Role includes:
 attendance at meetings and active in planning/implementing the fundraising strategy. Great for those who are professional, out-going, comfortable talking on the phone and in-person, have a strong command of the English language, and respect confidentiality with information gathered. Experienced in Excel and Word a must.

Box Office – Be where the action happens – and keep track of it too!
Role includes: cash management, ticket sales, complimentary ticket and waitlist coordination, cash reconciliation, provide general information for festival events. Great for those who love interacting with the public and are good with numbers.

Theatre Ushers – The welcoming face of the festival!
Role includes: ticket taker, assist guests into the theatre, coordinate wait lines, provide general information for festival events, hand out surveys/film guides. Great for those who enjoy interacting with the public and providing a exceptional service.

Special Events – The life of the party!
Role includes: Set up, clean up, break down, hospitality, coat check, ticket taker, food and beverage service, bussing. Great for those who can shift from one job to the next and have a keen eye for detail.

Read article




March 30, 2016

Advertise with us!

The Grand River Film Festival prints 3,000 programme guides each year, distributed before the festival, to various downtown locations and organizations across Waterloo Region. By advertising with GRFF, your organization will reach a community of loyal film fans and film industry professionals. 

Download our 2017 Rate Card

Read article


CineSeries – You Are Here – Nov 14


March 30, 2016

When: Wednesday, November 14, 7:30pm
Where: Galaxy Cinemas, Cambridge Centre
355 Hespeler Rd., Cambridge
See Map: Google Maps

Canada, 2018, Documentary, 84 minutes, English

Director: Moze Mossanen

YOU ARE HERE: A COME FROM AWAY STORY travels deep within this unique tale to shine a light on the actual Newfoundlanders and passengers whose lives have inspired the musical. This includes the mayors of Gander and Appleton, Newfoundland, community workers, police officers, TV reporters, and more – all real-life people who worked tirelessly alongside countless others to comfort and care for their unexpected guests. The documentary also highlights the real-life passengers who were looked after during those five unforgettable days, including a couple who met, fell in love, and ultimately honeymooned in Gander, the pilot of an American Airlines jet whose life was turned upside down, and a U.S. businessman who was so touched by his hosts’ generosity that he went on to create Good Samaritan initiatives in cities such as Austin, Texas.

After the Screening we will be doing a Q&A with the Director Moze Mossanen



Read article


Youth Video Competition


March 30, 2016

Once again, the City of Kitchener and the Kitchener Public Library,
are hosting a competition for youth ages 12-25 to submit short videos
or films. This is an exciting opportunity for aspiring filmmakers to
express their creativity, win prizes, have their videos showcased in
the community and meet film industry professionals.Please share this news with students or young people that have a
passion for film

•Three age categories:  12-14,   15-17,    18-25
•Six winners receive $300 cash prizes each; Honourable Mentions also
win prizes
•Submission deadline: March 29, 2019, 5 p.m.
•Winners and Honourable Mentions will have the opportunity to have
their films screened before live audiences at the Grand River Film
Festival in May 2019.

Find the submission form and learn more about the contest at or contact me directly with any
Karoline Varin Program Administrator
Arts & Creative Industries| Economic Development | City of Kitchener
519.741.2200 ext.7912

Read article